FX Replay and Secuora are the most directly comparable pair in this series: both are web-based bar-replay backtesters where you jump to a historical date, replay candles forward, and trade with simulated orders — and both run prop-firm challenge simulations. FX Replay’s charting is literally powered by TradingView, and its replay experience draws strong praise (Trustpilot ~4.1, "feels exactly like trading live").
The structural difference is the bundle. FX Replay’s journal covers your simulated trades only — it cannot import or log your real live trading. Secuora pairs the replay backtester with a full trading journal in one app: the same place that replays history also tracks your live trades, emotions, rule compliance and a community leaderboard.
Secuora vs FX Replay at a glance
| Feature | Secuora | FX Replay |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Journal (20 trades) + replay: 2 sessions/mo, 10 market-days & 50 trades each, sessions never expire, no card | Free forever — 2 sessions, 50 trades/session, 1 indicator, 1-week data retention |
| Paid pricing | Pro $29/mo, or $23/mo billed yearly — all markets, everything | Intermediate $17.99/mo or $180/yr; Pro $35/mo or $350/yr (as of June 2026) |
| Futures replay | Included in Pro (NQ, ES…) — intraday on recent windows, deep daily history beyond | CME futures data — Pro plan ($35/mo) only, not on Intermediate |
| Sub-minute view | 30-second view derived from 1-minute candles | True seconds-level data — Pro plan only |
| Charting | Custom replay terminal — indicators, drawing tools, multi-timeframe sync | Powered by TradingView — identical look/feel to live TradingView |
| Journal for live trades | Yes — manual logging with emotions, rules, confluences, screenshots, calendar | ✗ |
| Journal for backtest trades | ✓ | ✓ |
| Prop-firm challenge sim | ✓ | ✓ |
| Community | Community leaderboard | Not an advertised feature (as of June 2026) |
| AI coach | AI backtester (plain-English strategy in, deterministic backtest out); no AI sim-trade coach | Yes — query-limited by plan |
| FX history depth | Historical replay; deeper history on Pro | Majors back to ~2003 |
FX Replay facts verified against fxreplay.com/pricing and support docs plus 2026 reviews and Trustpilot, June 2026.
Where FX Replay is genuinely stronger
The charts. "Charting powered by TradingView" means every drawing tool, indicator behavior and shortcut works exactly like the TradingView you already use live — reviewers consistently call the replay feel best-in-class. Its forex history is also deep (majors back to roughly 2003), it offers an AI trade coach, and its support has a strong reputation, including honored refunds.
If you want seconds-level candles, FX Replay’s Pro plan has true seconds data (Secuora’s finest view is 30-second bars derived from 1-minute data).
Where Secuora is stronger
The bundle: FX Replay journals simulated trades only — independent reviews note it cannot replace a dedicated journal for your live account. Secuora is that journal: live-trade logging with emotions, rules and confluences, a P&L calendar, full analytics and a community leaderboard, plus the replay backtester — one subscription instead of a backtester + a separate journal.
Free-tier usability: FX Replay’s free plan caps you at 2 sessions, 50 trades per session, 1 indicator and one week of data retention — reviewers call it insufficient for real training. Secuora’s free tier is shaped similarly (2 sessions, 50 trades each, 10 market-days per session) but sessions never expire, the 20-trade journal is included, and the demo needs no account at all.
Futures access price: futures data sits behind FX Replay’s $35/month Pro plan; Secuora includes futures (NQ, ES…) in its $29/month Pro ($23/month yearly). One honest caveat the other way: FX Replay’s CME feed carries deeper intraday futures history, while Secuora serves intraday futures on recent windows with deep daily history beyond that.
Choose Secuora if you…
- want one tool for backtesting and your live trading journal
- trade futures and want CME data at the lower price point
- journal psychology — emotions, rule compliance, confluences
- want a community leaderboard
- want a free tier you can actually practice on (bar-by-bar crypto replay + a real journal)
Choose FX Replay if you…
- want charting that is literally TradingView — zero adjustment
- need true seconds-level candles (Secuora’s finest view is 30-second bars)
- backtest mainly forex majors and want history back to ~2003
- want an AI coach reviewing your sim trades
Frequently asked questions
Is Secuora a good FX Replay alternative?
Yes — both are web-based bar-replay backtesters with simulated order execution and prop-firm challenge modes. The structural difference: Secuora also includes a full journal for your live trading (emotions, rules, calendar, analytics) and a community leaderboard, while FX Replay journals simulated trades only.
Is FX Replay free?
FX Replay has a free-forever plan, but it is tightly capped as of June 2026: 2 backtesting sessions, 50 trades per session, 1 indicator and one week of data retention. Secuora’s free plan is capped similarly on sessions (2, with 10 market-days and 50 trades each) but its sessions never expire, a 20-trade journal is included, and the live demo needs no sign-up at all.
Which is better for ICT / Smart Money Concepts backtesting?
Both work well for ICT-style practice: replay real markets, mark session highs/lows, and wait for setups like fair value gaps without seeing the future. FX Replay is popular in the ICT community and has TradingView-native charting; Secuora adds session-open skipping (London/New York/Asia), a 30-second chart view, futures included at $29/month, and a journal that tracks rule compliance per trade.
Which is cheaper for futures backtesting?
Secuora — futures like NQ and ES are part of Pro at $29/month or $23/month billed yearly, with intraday data on recent windows and deep daily history beyond. On FX Replay, futures require the Pro plan at $35/month or $350/year (its $17.99 Intermediate plan has no futures or stocks data), in exchange for deeper CME intraday history.