Edgewonk has been the serious journaler’s journal for years, and the current web-based Edgewonk 3 ships everything in one $197-per-12-months plan: the Psychology Lab (emotion, discipline and mistake tracking), 50+ customizable reports, Edge Finder scans, unlimited journals and trades across forex, stocks, futures, crypto, commodities, indices and options. Its Trustpilot score sits around 4.7/5 — from a small base of roughly 40 reviews — and reviewers consistently single out the depth of its analytics. If the question is "which tool will make me sit with my mistakes," Edgewonk is one of the best answers in the category.
The catch is the word "backtester." Edgewonk’s Backtester tab is manual backtest journaling — you type in hypothetical trade outcomes as R-multiples, currency or percentages — and its Simulator projects equity curves from your logged stats. Neither replays a market. Secuora comes from the opposite direction: a bar-replay backtester on real historical charts with the journal built in, a free plan, and a monthly billing option Edgewonk doesn’t offer. Here is the honest breakdown.
Secuora vs Edgewonk at a glance
| Feature | Secuora | Edgewonk |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes — journal (20 trades) + crypto replay, no card | No free plan or trial — 14-day money-back guarantee instead (as of June 2026) |
| Pricing | Pro $29/mo, or $23/mo billed yearly ($276/yr) | One plan: $197 per 12 months (≈$16.40/mo, VAT extra) — no monthly option (as of June 2026) |
| Cheapest paid year | $276 ($23/mo billed yearly) | $197 — and a June 2026 promo adds 3 free months to the first term |
| Bar-replay backtesting | Yes — real historical charts, 1-minute to monthly plus a 30-second view, SL/TP and partial closes | No — the Backtester tab is manual entry of hypothetical results; the Simulator projects equity curves from your stats |
| Prop-firm practice | Challenge simulator — targets, daily loss, max drawdown on historical data | ✗ |
| AI | AI backtester — plain-English strategies compiled to a deterministic engine (no AI trade review) | No AI layer (as of June 2026) |
| Broker auto-sync | ✗ | MetaTrader 4/5 documented; other brokers via statement/CSV upload |
| Journaling | Emotions, rules, confluences, screenshots, P&L calendar; replay trades log automatically | Psychology Lab — emotion, discipline and mistake tracking, custom checklists, trading diary; unlimited trades and journals |
| Analytics | Confluence analytics, session stats, P&L calendar | 50+ customizable reports, Edge Finder, Chart Lab, R-multiple and expectancy tracking |
| Markets | Crypto on free; Pro adds forex, stocks, indices, futures (NQ/ES), metals | Forex, stocks, futures, crypto, commodities, indices, options |
| Try before paying | Live demo (no sign-up) + free plan (no card) | Pay $197 first; 14-day no-questions refund |
Edgewonk facts verified against edgewonk.com (pricing page, feature pages, Backtester/Simulator posts) and its Zendesk import docs plus 2026 independent reviews, June 11, 2026. Older articles describing a one-time-purchase desktop app refer to the legacy Edgewonk 2 — the current Edgewonk 3 is a web subscription.
Where Edgewonk is genuinely stronger
Journaling depth. The Psychology Lab — emotion and discipline tracking, mistake tracking, custom checklists you can assign per setup, an integrated diary — is Edgewonk’s signature, and reviewers repeatedly call it the best discipline framework in the category. Around it sit 50+ customizable reports, the Edge Finder scan that surfaces strengths and weaknesses automatically, Chart Lab visuals, R-multiple and expectancy tracking, and unlimited journals, accounts and trades on the single plan. Secuora’s journal (emotions, rules, confluences, screenshots, P&L calendar) is solid but lighter, and its free tier caps the journal at 20 trades.
Price per year. Do the math honestly: $197 per 12 months is about $16.40/month, versus $276/year ($23/month) for Secuora Pro billed yearly — roughly $79/year less, before Edgewonk’s June 2026 promo adds 3 free months to the first term. Add VAT at checkout depending on your country, but the full-year value still favors Edgewonk, and the 14-day, no-questions money-back guarantee removes most of the up-front risk.
Where Secuora is stronger
Backtesting that replays the market. Per Edgewonk’s own docs, its Backtester tab is manual data entry — you record hypothetical outcomes and compare two strategy variations — and the Simulator only projects equity curves from your existing stats. Secuora’s backtester puts you on real historical charts bar by bar (1-minute to monthly, plus a derived 30-second view) with simulated SL/TP, partial closes and session-open skips, runs prop-firm challenge rules on top, and logs every replay trade into the journal automatically. There is also an AI backtester that compiles a plain-English strategy into a deterministic engine — Edgewonk has no AI layer at all as of June 2026.
Entry friction and billing. Edgewonk requires $197 up front, annual-only, with no free plan or trial (the 14-day refund is a safety net, not a try-before-you-buy). Secuora starts at $0 — a free plan with no card and a live demo with no sign-up — and offers a $29 monthly option if you don’t want a 12-month commitment.
Workflow weight. One hands-on reviewer who tested seven journals said Edgewonk "feels like homework," and others note the interface takes a while to learn; its value depends on disciplined manual logging. Secuora’s replay trades record in the session automatically and push to the journal in one click. The honest caveat in both directions: Secuora’s live trades are manual too — it has no broker sync of any kind, where Edgewonk at least auto-syncs MetaTrader 4/5 and imports statements from other brokers.
Choose Secuora if you…
- want to backtest on real charts — bar-by-bar replay with SL/TP and partial closes, not manual entry of hypothetical results
- want to start at $0: free plan with no card, live demo with no sign-up
- prefer a $29 monthly option over a $197 annual-only commitment
- are rehearsing a prop-firm evaluation (profit target, daily loss, max drawdown) on historical data
- want replay trades journaled automatically instead of hand-logging every backtest
Choose Edgewonk if you…
- want the deepest discipline framework in the category — Psychology Lab, mistake tracking, custom trade checklists
- want the lowest full-year price: $197 per 12 months (≈$16.40/mo) vs $276/year for Secuora Pro
- trade through MetaTrader 4/5 and want its documented auto-sync, plus statement importers for other brokers
- prefer a 14-day money-back guarantee on the full product over a capped free tier
Frequently asked questions
Is Secuora a good Edgewonk alternative?
For backtesting-led improvement, yes: Secuora pairs a bar-replay backtester (with a prop-firm challenge mode and an AI backtester) with the journal in one app, starting free. If your improvement loop is journaling-led — deep emotion, discipline and mistake analysis of your live trades — Edgewonk’s Psychology Lab and 50+ reports go deeper than Secuora’s journal does.
Does Edgewonk have backtesting?
Not in the bar-replay sense. Edgewonk’s Backtester tab is manual backtest journaling — you enter hypothetical trade outcomes as R-multiples, currency or percentages and compare two strategy variations — and its Trade Simulator projects equity curves from your logged stats. There is no chart-based or market-replay backtesting. Secuora’s backtester replays real historical charts bar by bar with simulated SL/TP and partial closes.
Which is cheaper, Secuora or Edgewonk?
Per paid year, Edgewonk: one $197-per-12-months plan (≈$16.40/month, VAT added at checkout) versus $276/year for Secuora Pro billed yearly — about $79/year less, and a June 2026 promo adds 3 free months to the first term. Secuora is cheaper to start: a free plan with no card, and a $29 month-to-month option with no annual commitment. Edgewonk has no free plan and no monthly billing.
Is Edgewonk a one-time purchase?
Not anymore. Articles describing a one-time-fee desktop app refer to the legacy Edgewonk 2. The current Edgewonk 3 is a web-based subscription billed $197 per 12 months — and some older reviews still cite a $169 price, but the official pricing page showed $197 as of June 11, 2026.
Does Edgewonk have a free trial?
No free plan and no free trial — you pay $197 up front, protected by a 14-day, no-questions-asked money-back guarantee. Some reviews loosely call this a "14-day trial," but it is a refund window after payment, not try-before-you-buy. Secuora has a free plan with no card and a live demo with no sign-up.